New York Beanery Information

Walking into New York Beanery at 114 Merrick Rd in Amityville, you’re immediately greeted by a cozy, welcoming vibe that feels like the perfect spot for a casual breakfast or a laid-back lunch. The menu offers a fantastic mix of classic diner comfort foods alongside inventive twists that make every visit feel fresh. Whether you’re craving a hearty stack of pancakes or a loaded omelet, the kitchen seems to nail both traditional and creative options, and portions are generous enough that leaving hungry is practically impossible. Coffee lovers will appreciate the freshly brewed selections that pair beautifully with everything from buttery pastries to savory sandwiches, and the attention to quality shows in every cup. The atmosphere is relaxed but energetic, with a friendly staff that balances efficiency with genuine warmth, making it clear they care about the experience as much as the food. Locals often mention that service here feels personal, like a regular diner that remembers your name and your favorite order, which adds a comforting layer to the dining experience. Reviews frequently highlight not just the food but the little details-the way breakfast potatoes are perfectly crisped, the toast is always golden brown, and even the kids’ menu is thoughtfully crafted. Seating is ample without feeling cramped, and natural light streams in during the day, making it a pleasant place to linger over a mid-morning coffee or weekend brunch. Beyond breakfast, the lunch offerings stand out with fresh sandwiches, hearty salads, and daily specials that showcase seasonal ingredients, keeping the menu interesting even for repeat visits. Prices feel fair for the quality and portion sizes, and the overall vibe of the diner makes it a favorite among families, friends meeting for a catch-up, or anyone looking for a relaxed, satisfying meal. With consistent positive feedback across reviews and a location that’s easy to find, New York Beanery manages to blend that classic diner comfort with touches of thoughtful culinary care, making it a spot worth checking out whenever you’re in Amityville.

Business Info

What People's Say About Place

I was in the area for a business meeting and didn’t have time for breakfast at home. Searched in google for good breakfast spots and this place came up. I’m happy it did! Went here 2 mornings back to back. The coffee/ice coffee was so delicious and fresh! The breakfast was scrumptious and very good amount. Customer service was great and I was able to prep for meetings within the place with their free wifi available. I’d definitely recommend this place to everyone!

i got the rose matcha and the turkey club panini and they were amazing. will definitely be coming back to try their other drinks. they have so much variety of food and sell bubble tea as well! love the atmosphere and the staff is friendly :)

New York Beanery in Amityville has some super unique and tasty options! They just launched their Summer 2024 menu items! I really loved: + the tiramasu iced latte + rose matcha + mango matcha + crossiants and pasteries + the avocado toast with tomatoe jam + savory breakfast burritos Donna and her team are so kind and funny. I love the little coffee shop and trendy snacks. There’s plenty of parking at the public lot 100ft away from the coffee shop!

One of my favorite coffee shops around! Truly amazing seasonal drinks. Many of the syrups are made in house. The espresso is strong enough to stand up to the other flavors. Matcha lattes are also good, but are occasionally ever so slightly milky. However the quality of the matcha is still high enough that it doesn't dissuade me.

There are a few things that weren't perfect. For instance, mango bubble tea tasted nothing like mango (just lots of sugar) and the place needs blinds on windows (it was hot sitting at the table). Despite that, we liked the place a lot and will be back :)

Really cute place to hang out. They had very fun specialty drinks and a pretty big menu, I wanted to try them all! The breakfast burrito was also very good. Looking forward to going back to trying more drinks and desserts, wish it was closer to home. Also there is a little parking lot, wasn't hard to find parking.

My go to place before work. Smorgasbord of options and flavors. Breakfast is always fresh and tasty as is the tea and coffee.

The food was sooooooo good, I wish i lived close so I can eat here more often and try everything Thanks to all the people who cooked my meal, made my matcha latte and served it to my table. You all deserve a raise!

New York Beanery

New York Beanery Information

Most Popular Dishes

Open Times

New York Beanery Gallery

Business Info

Location & Contact

What People's Say About Place

Places Nearby

Ann's Seafood

Hangang Ramen 한강라면

4 Corners Pizzeria

Cameo By The Lake

Char Grill